Where to stay

Where to stay in Key West: neighborhoods and types of lodging

Large Victorian house with a turret, red roof and wide pale blue verandas, surrounded by palm trees under a cloudy sky
Photo: DΛVΞ GΛRCIΛ / Pexels

We may earn a commission when you book through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We don't visit or try the places we cover: we summarize published sources. How we work

In short

  • For a first stay, Old Town is the most practical: Duval Street, the harbor, museums and restaurants are all on foot, without a car.
  • Truman Annex and the harbor area are calmer; Casa Marina and the Atlantic side suit a beach-style stay; Midtown and New Town are cheaper but less charming.
  • Plan two nights to see the essentials and three to add a boat trip or a Dry Tortugas excursion.
  • Many properties add mandatory fees and charge parking per night: compare the final total, taxes and fees included.

Key West is a small island, but the neighborhood you sleep in changes the experience a lot. In Old Town, you hear the music of Duval Street’s bars late into the evening; two or three streets away, there are verandas, tropical gardens and roaming chickens. Farther east, the island becomes more conventional, with big hotels, parking lots and shopping centers. This guide compares the main areas and lodging types to help you choose, as a complement to the guide to visiting Key West.

The key takeaway: for a short stay, sleep in Old Town or right next to it, from where you can do everything on foot. Lodging farther away is often cheaper, but will quickly force you to take a bike, bus or taxi. In all cases, prices are high compared with the rest of the Keys, and extra fees (parking, service fees) can weigh on the bill.

Old Town: the historic heart, on foot to everything

Old Town is Key West’s historic district and the one where most visitors stay. You find the wooden houses with verandas, the harbor, museums, galleries, bars and restaurants. Its big advantage is that you get around on foot: Ernest Hemingway’s house, the lighthouse, the harbor and the sunset promenade are all reachable without a car.

Sleeping here means accepting a compromise. The streets around Duval Street are lively in the evening, especially at the end of the week, and music can run late. Guesthouses and small hotels in the area are often quieter when they are on a side street, a few minutes from the main artery. Read recent reviews on noise and ask for a room facing the courtyard or garden rather than the street.

Rates are among the highest on the island, especially in high season. In return, you save the cost of a car and parking, which are rare and often paid in the center.

🏨

Compare lodging in Key West

Guesthouses in Old Town, hotels near the harbor or quieter places: compare availability for your dates and filter free-cancellation offers.

See lodging Compare on Booking.com

Truman Annex and the harbor area: calm, history and sea views

Truman Annex and the harbor area: calm, history and sea views
Photo: Florida Keys--Public Libraries from Key West, Fla., USA / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Northwest of Old Town, the former military site of Truman Annex is now a residential and tourist neighborhood, with restored houses, tree-lined streets and easy access to the harbor. The Little White House, where President Harry S. Truman regularly stayed, is there. The area is calmer than Duval Street while remaining a few minutes’ walk away.

Nearby, the harbor area (Historic Seaport) concentrates hotels, restaurants overlooking the boats and departures for boat trips. You are well placed there if you plan a boat excursion, snorkeling or the departure for the Dry Tortugas, detailed in the Key West guide. The drawback is the price, often high, and the crowds during the day when cruise ships call.

Atlantic side: Casa Marina and seafront hotels

Atlantic side: Casa Marina and seafront hotels
Photo: John Hank / Pexels

On the island’s south coast, facing the Atlantic, several large hotels and resorts offer a pool, sea access and full services. This is the area to favor if you want a more beach-style stay, with the comfort of a large property. Key West’s beaches are modest: the sand is often partly brought in and the stretches are small, which is a point to keep in mind if you come mostly to swim.

These hotels suit families and couples who prioritize relaxation. The historic center remains reachable on foot or by bike in a few minutes depending on the location, but the distance depends on the property: check it on the map before booking. Service fees, parking fees and the price of beach equipment can be added to the room rate.

Midtown and New Town: more choice, less charm

Farther east, Midtown and New Town form the modern part of the island, with motels, chain hotels, apartments, supermarkets and shopping centers. Key West’s airport is on this side. The historic center is at a distance that calls for a bike, city bus or taxi rather than a walk.

Rates there are generally more affordable, and parking is easier. It is a reasonable option if you travel by car, if you have a tight budget or if you can no longer find availability in Old Town. Keep in mind, however, that you lose the option of walking home after an evening out, and that the atmosphere there is far less picturesque.

🚗

Compare rental companies for the Keys road

If you arrive from Miami along the Overseas Highway, compare rental companies and check the parking cost at your lodging.

Compare rental companies

Which type of lodging to choose in Key West

Guesthouses and small charming hotels in Old Town often occupy former wooden houses, with a garden or pool and breakfast. They have a lot of character, but rooms are sometimes small, rules stricter (minimum age for children, minimum stay in high season) and rates high.

Large hotels and resorts offer a pool, services and often sea access. They are practical for families and relaxation stays, with the trade-off of service and parking fees to check.

Chain hotels and motels in Midtown and New Town are more affordable and often easier to reach by car. They suit a limited budget or a one-night stop.

Apartments and short-term rentals work well for a group or a stay of several nights, with a kitchen and space. Check local regulations, which govern some rentals, as well as cleaning fees, cancellation terms and the exact location.

Camping exists in the Keys, notably on some neighboring islands. It generally requires a vehicle and a booking made very far ahead: ask the parks directly before planning.

To measure the effect of these choices on your overall budget, see the guide to the budget for an East Coast trip.

When to book and how to limit the bill

High season runs from winter to spring, with pleasant weather and rising prices. Summer is hotter and more humid, with frequent thunderstorms, and the hurricane season officially runs from June to November: be sure to choose a cancellable booking. Long weekends, year-end holidays and big island events push prices up and fill lodging, sometimes long in advance. The article on when to go to the East Coast details these periods.

A few habits to keep control of the budget:

  • book early for high season, with free cancellation;
  • always compare the final price, mandatory fees and taxes included;
  • look at lodging on the edge of Old Town rather than at the foot of Duval Street;
  • check the cost of parking before renting a car, or go without a car there;
  • compare weekday and weekend nights, because the gap can be large;
  • consider Midtown or New Town if Old Town exceeds your budget, allowing for a bike or taxi.

Getting around from your lodging

The island is small and flat, which makes it ideal for biking, which is very common among visitors. Many properties lend or rent bikes, which is a criterion to check when booking. A city bus network serves the island, and taxis and ride-hailing complete the offer in the evening. For short trips in Old Town, walking remains the simplest solution.

If you come from Miami, the Overseas Highway is about 155 miles (250 km) and nearly four hours of driving without stops. Allow half a day if you want to stop along the way, and choose lodging that allows an easy departure the next day. Before taking the road, reread the guide to where to stay in Miami and the 3-day Miami itinerary to organize the first stage of your Florida stay.

🎟️

Boat trips and excursions in Key West

Snorkeling, sunset cruise, excursion to the Dry Tortugas: compare available activities before you leave.

See activities

Staying connected, insurance and formalities

To stay connected, check your carrier’s international plan or use a travel eSIM; Saily offers plans in more than 150 countries, so check the offer for the United States. To compare the options, read the guide to SIM cards and eSIMs on the East Coast.

Entry rules depend on your passport. Check the official travel advice of your government before you book: travel.state.gov (US), GOV.UK (UK), travel.gc.ca (Canada), Smartraveller (Australia) (checked November 2026). The article on East Coast formalities gives more context. Because medical costs are very high in the United States, travel insurance is recommended.

📱

Stay connected in the United States

Saily offers eSIM plans in more than 150 countries; check the offer for the United States before you leave.

See the offer

Key West, a stop on a Florida trip

Key West, a stop on a Florida trip
Photo: Zoshua Colah / Unsplash

Key West combines naturally with Miami, the starting point of the Keys road. Two nights are enough for a stopover; three to four nights leave room for a boat trip, the museums and long evenings at the harbor. Many travelers prefer to sleep in Key West rather than make a round trip in a day: the road is long and you would miss the sunset, the island’s highlight.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best neighborhood to stay in Key West?

For a first stay, Old Town is the most practical choice: Duval Street, the harbor, museums and restaurants are all on foot, without a car. If you want more calm, the residential streets away from Duval Street or the Truman Annex area offer a quieter atmosphere while staying close to the center.

Do you need a car to stay in Key West?

Not if you sleep in Old Town: the island is small and flat, and you get around on foot, by bike, by city bus or by taxi. A car is mostly useful to arrive from Miami along the Overseas Highway. In that case, check before booking whether the lodging has parking and whether it is paid, because spaces are limited in the center.

How many nights should you plan in Key West?

Two nights let you see the essentials of the island, three nights leave time to add a boat trip or an excursion to the Dry Tortugas. Many travelers come as a day trip from Miami, but the road is long: sleeping there lets you enjoy the sunset and the evening atmosphere.

Do Key West hotels have extra fees?

Yes, many properties add mandatory fees ("resort fees" or service fees) and charge parking per night. They do not always appear in the first price shown. Always compare the final total, taxes and fees included, before confirming.

What is the best time to book lodging in Key West?

Winter and spring are high season, with pleasant weather and higher prices. Summer is hotter and more humid, and the hurricane season officially runs from June to November. Events and holiday weekends push rates up: book early, with a free-cancellation option.

Is Key West suited to families?

Yes, provided you choose lodging carefully. Hotels with a pool and apartments with a kitchen suit families well. Some guesthouses do not accept children: check the property's policy before booking. Sleep away from the liveliest streets if you have young children.

Are Key West guesthouses adults-only?

Some are, others are not. The age policy is stated on each property's page: read it before booking, as well as the cancellation terms and any minimum-stay requirements in high season.

More US East Coast guides

Keep reading

Ready-made

US East Coast itineraries

Keep exploring

Other destinations nearby

Photo: Joseph Walker / Pexels

Montreal, Quebec City & the St. Lawrence · Canada

Quebec

Montreal and Quebec City, Charlevoix and the whales of Tadoussac, the Eastern Townships, Mont-Tremblant and the Gaspé Peninsula.

18 guides4 itinerariesTrip planner

Photo: Ella Ragasa / Pexels

Beaches, bays & colonial city · Dominican Republic

Dominican Republic

Santo Domingo's colonial zone, the beaches of Punta Cana and Bayahibe, Saona island, the Samaná peninsula and the north coast.

18 guides3 itinerariesTrip planner

Photo: Israel Torres / Pexels

Yucatán & beyond · Mexico

Mexico

Mayan ruins, cenotes and colonial towns, from the Yucatán Peninsula to the highlands.

18 guides4 itinerariesTrip planner